User loginUpcoming eventsWho's newWho's onlineThere are currently 0 users and 0 guests online.
SearchActive forum topics |
F1 "dumbed down?"Here is an article about how Eddie Irvine has recently said that F1 has been dumbed down: Former world championship contender Eddie Irvine has claimed that Formula 1 is being 'dumbed down'. Irvine, who fought for the 1999 title with Ferrari and also raced for Jordan and Jaguar during his nine-year F1 career, supported Alain Prost's recent suggestion that driver skill now played a smaller part than ever. "There's a quote attributed to Ernest Hemingway when he said: 'There are only three sports: bullfighting, motor racing and mountaineering; all the rest are merely games,'" Irvine wrote in a column for The Guardian newspaper. "Formula 1 seems intent on trying to become a game. "By taking increasing measures to slow things down the FIA is turning Formula 1 into tiddlywinks. "It is nearly impossible to have an accident in F1 now, you just go into the sand traps. "The sport has been dumbed down and it's not Formula 1. "Before, if you made a mistake while battling to overtake, you would be in danger of flying into a barrier . "Now it's not much of a gladiatorial contest." Irvine believes the removal of traction control this season will have little effect. "In terms of reducing driver aids to increase the skills employed in a race, getting rid of traction control will make very little difference save in exceptionally wet conditions," he said. "The easiest thing to do is come out of a corner on the throttle; braking and turning is the hardest part. "Yes, you need to concentrate a little bit more but for drivers at this level a lack of traction control won't be a major difficulty." But Damon Hill disagreed with Irvine and suggested that drivers' talent was still a vital ingredient despite the increased technology in F1. "Drivers' skill is probably as great as it ever was; it is the area that the driver works in that is much more restricted than it used to be," he told the newspaper. "Some of the regulations are being changed to restore the element of racing ability and take away some of the emphasis on really quite obscure technology. "The public, after all, wants to see who is the best driver rather than which is the best team. "The true power of the sport is the spectacle of man and machine competing against each other." What do you all think?? |
F1 of InterestPhotos |
Driver Are Important, but F1 Needs both Speed and Innovation
What first drew me to be an F1 fan ahead of the other race circuits were the incredible speeds the cars reached while still negotiating a course with tight turns. I think that physics should be the only limitation to the design and innovation of the cars. Manufacturers and designers should be able to use any technology available to allow the cars to negotiate the race course and still win races. Every rule that has been made in recent years has brought F1 closer to a spec series, like Champ Car, IRL or NASCAR.
That being said, no matter what features are put into the cars, quality drivers will still need to race them. The combination of the right driver and the right car should be the deciding factor in the races, not rule changes or FIA sanctions. As a fan, all I want is to see the best drivers, the best teams, the newest amazing technologies, and the fastest speeds all taking place in beautiful world venues.
I agree that F1 seems to
I agree that F1 seems to becoming more of a "spec series" especially now with the introduction of standardized ECUs, tires, budget caps, etc. One might as well go to GP2 or something of the likes.
I am hoping we will see exciting advances in "green" technologies and that will make F1 very cutting edge and relevant, but it seems as though that is still a few seasons off...
I think I read a quote from Schumacher where he claimed that, without restrictions, he believed an F1 car could get up to 500mph. That'd be amazing to see!
But even though I'd love to see unrestricted cars, I have to say that the reason I stopped watching F1 for nearly a decade was of the loss of Ayrton Senna. I just couldn't bear to watch it. I know there are those who loved the Schumi era, but my heart ached every time I watched a race. I think its wonderful how safe the sport now is, and perhaps Irvine is right that it has made it less challenging, but at least now, our heros can live to race another season...
http://www.sfrecording.com